The Best Hotels in Put-in-Bay, Ohio, United States from 2025

Name of hotel	Accommodation Rating	Price, $
Chapman House	8.2 / 10 (51 Reviews)	From 314£
Islander Inn	8.1 / 10 (332 Reviews)	From 121£
Bayshore Resort At Put-in-Bay	7.6 / 10 (124 Reviews)	From 579£
Put-in-Bay Victory Station	8.8 / 10 (63 Reviews)	From 154£

Chapman House

50 Chapman Road

Chapman House is a beautifully restored historic hotel that enchants guests with its storied past and charming atmosphere. Originally built in the late 1800s, this boutique hotel features vintage architecture and decor that reflect the island's rich history. Each room is thoughtfully appointed, incorporating elegant accents with modern amenities for a comfortable stay. The property’s gardens and outdoor seating areas invite guests to soak in the serene atmosphere while contemplating the island's landmarks. Its prime location further enhances the experience, nestled near local attractions that celebrate the history of Put-in-Bay. For those drawn to the allure of the past, Chapman House provides a captivating haven that evokes the spirit of a bygone era.

From

314£ /per night

Islander Inn

225 Erie St

Islander Inn promotes a quirky atmosphere that is sure to delight guests looking for something beyond the ordinary. The hotel features colorful decor and a welcoming vibe that adds an element of fun to your stay. Its outdoor amenities, including an entertaining pool area, create a vibrant social spot for guests to unwind and connect. Additionally, the hotel frequently hosts fun events that celebrate the lively spirit of Put-in-Bay, making for unexpected surprises during your visit. From themed decor to a light-hearted ambiance, Islander Inn caters to those seeking a lively experience while enjoying the comforts of home. If you’re in search of a place with character and charm, you’ll find it here at this fun-loving hotel.

From

121£ /per night

Family-Friendly Put-in-Bay Hotels

When visiting Put-in-Bay with family, choosing accommodations that cater to all ages is essential. This section highlights hotels that prioritize family-friendly amenities and activities, ensuring everyone has a fun and enjoyable experience. These Put-in-Bay hotels offer features such as swimming pools, spacious rooms, and easy access to local attractions, creating a home away from home. Families can enjoy a variety of recreational opportunities right on the premises or nearby, making it easy to spend quality time together. From playing by the pool to exploring the island's scenic spots, these hotels make it easy for families to create lasting memories. Discover the best family-oriented hotels that make Put-in-Bay an ideal destination for your next vacation!

Bayshore Resort At Put-in-Bay

328 Toledo Avenue

Bayshore Resort At Put-in-Bay is another excellent option for families seeking a fun vacation. This scenic resort features a variety of rooms and suites, providing plenty of space for families to settle in comfortably. Located near key attractions like the Put-in-Bay Aquatic Center, families can easily access exciting activities without straying far from their hotel. The on-site restaurant offers a children’s menu, ensuring even picky eaters find something they enjoy. Guests can also take advantage of the outdoor pool, complete with sun loungers for parents to relax while the kids splash around. With its family-focused offerings, Bayshore Resort ensures a memorable stay for guests of all ages.

From

579£ /per night

Put-in-Bay Victory Station

489 Catawba Ave

Put-in-Bay Victory Station also extends a warm welcome to pet owners seeking a comfortable stay on the island. This hotel recognizes the bond between guests and their pets and allows dogs and cats to accompany their owners during the visit. Its proximity to outdoor parks and scenic areas makes it easy for pet owners to explore the island while enjoying time with their furry friends. The hotel offers pet-friendly rooms and outdoor areas where guests can relax with their animals. With friendly staff that understands the needs of both pets and owners, it creates an environment where everyone feels at home. For a pet-friendly getaway, Put-in-Bay Victory Station stands out as an excellent choice.

From

154£ /per night