Tourist VR
flag

Shelter Island Hotels

Shelter Island
Jan 31, 2025 - Feb 01, 2025
2 adults, 1 room
Find
Tourist VR
United States Hotels
New York State Hotels
Shelter Island Hotels

Discover Your Perfect Stay

Welcome to Shelter Island, a picturesque destination off the coast of New York, where tranquility meets natural beauty. Whether you're seeking a peaceful getaway or a memorable vacation, Shelter Island has it all. And when it comes to finding the perfect place to stay, look no further than the hotels on Shelter Island. From charming boutique hotels with stunning waterfront views to luxurious resorts offering top-notch amenities, you'll be spoiled for choice when it comes to accommodations that cater to your every need. .

Immerse yourself in the island life at Hotel Shelter Island, where relaxation and comfort are the top priorities. Wake up to breathtaking sunrises over the water, and let the soothing sound of waves lull you into a state of serenity. Whether you opt for a cozy room with coastal-inspired decor or a spacious suite with a private terrace, the hotels on Shelter Island will make you feel right at home. Experience impeccable service from friendly staff who are dedicated to ensuring your stay is nothing short of extraordinary. .

Aside from the sheer comfort provided by the hotels on Shelter Island, there's a myriad of activities and attractions waiting to be explored. Take a leisurely stroll along the island's picturesque beaches, go for a dip in the crystal-clear waters, or embark on a scenic bike ride along the coastline. For the adventure enthusiasts, indulge in water sports such as kayaking, paddleboarding, or fishing. And when hunger strikes, you'll find a range of delightful restaurants and cafes, offering everything from fresh seafood to farm-to-table cuisine. With so much to see and do, Hotel Shelter Island is the perfect base for your island adventure. .

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
Sunset Beach

8.2 / 10

(8 Reviews)

 From 475£
Ram's Head Inn

7.9 / 10

(47 Reviews)

 From 324£
The Pridwin Hotel

9.4 / 10

(79 Reviews)

 From 266£
Sunset Beach

8.2 / 10

(8 Reviews)

 From 475£
Sunset Beach

8.2 / 10

(8 Reviews)

 From 475£
8.2
Very good (8)

Sunset Beach

4
35 Shore Road
Radiating the essence of waterfront bliss, Sunset Beach is a captivating hotel that allows guests to bask in the island's natural beauty. Set directly on the water, this boutique property offers stylish rooms with private balconies, allowing you to wake up to breathtaking sunrises and the gentle sound of waves. Unwind on the hotel's pristine beach or take a refreshing dip in the azure waters. .

From

475£ /per night
7.9
Very good (47)

Ram's Head Inn

3
108 Ram Island Drive
For an eco-friendly escape that celebrates the island's natural wonders, Ram's Head Inn is the perfect choice. This waterfront hotel takes pride in its efforts to reduce its environmental impact, from energy-efficient practices to the use of eco-friendly cleaning products. Enjoy spacious rooms with sustainable furnishings and breathtaking water views. Immerse yourself in nature with outdoor activities such as kayaking or hiking along the island's trails. .

From

324£ /per night

Boutique Charm at Hotel Shelter Island

Immerse yourself in the unique charm of Shelter Island with a stay at one of its boutique hotels. These hidden gems offer an intimate and personalized experience, perfectly combining comfort with the island's natural beauty. Be captivated by the tranquil surroundings and indulge in the utmost relaxation. .

9.4
Excellent (79)

The Pridwin Hotel

4
81 Shore Road
A true hidden gem on Shelter Island is a luxurious haven that boasts unrivaled hospitality and sweeping views of the island's natural wonders. This family-owned retreat offers elegantly appointed rooms and suites with private balconies or patios, allowing you to embrace the island atmosphere. Indulge in gourmet cuisine at the hotel's acclaimed restaurant, known for its farm-to-table dishes and fresh seafood. Enhance your experience with a dip in the outdoor pool or a rejuvenating massage at the spa. .

From

266£ /per night
8.2
Very good (8)

Sunset Beach

4
35 Shore Road
As a luxury hotel on Shelter Island offers an unparalleled experience for discerning travelers. This exclusive waterfront property mesmerizes guests with its elegant decor, impressive suites, and stunning ocean panoramas. Immerse yourself in pure bliss as you relax on your private terrace or indulge in the hotel's spa services. The hotel's renowned restaurant ensures fine dining, while the beach club provides a chic and vibrant atmosphere for sunbathing or sipping cocktails. .

From

475£ /per night

Luxury Retreats at Hotel Shelter Island

For those seeking the ultimate indulgence and upscale experience, Shelter Island's luxury hotels are sure to exceed your expectations. Elevate your stay with world-class amenities, impeccable service, and breathtaking views. .

8.2
Very good (8)

Sunset Beach

4
35 Shore Road
Bring the whole family together for a memorable stay at Sunset Beach, where luxury meets family-friendly amenities. This waterfront hotel offers spacious suites with separate bedrooms and living areas, ensuring plenty of space for everyone to relax and unwind. Kids will love the hotel's private beach, where they can build sandcastles and splash in the gentle waves. The hotel's family-friendly restaurant provides a wide range of options to satisfy even the pickiest eaters. .

From

475£ /per night
8.2
Very good (8)

Sunset Beach

4
35 Shore Road
Experience eco-luxury at Sunset Beach, where environmental sustainability meets upscale accommodations. The hotel employs sustainable practices throughout its operations, from energy-efficient lighting to eco-friendly toiletries. Relax in the hotel's organic cotton linens and enjoy the breathtaking views from your private balcony. The onsite restaurant emphasizes locally sourced ingredients and sustainable seafood. .

From

475£ /per night

Waterfront Bliss at Hotel Shelter Island

Experience the epitome of serenity and coastal living at Shelter Island's waterfront hotels. With the shimmering waters as your backdrop, escape into a world of tranquility and relaxation. .

7.9
Very good (47)

Ram's Head Inn

3
108 Ram Island Drive
Nestled on an idyllic waterfront location, Ram's Head Inn is a true sanctuary for luxury-seekers. This historic hotel envelops guests in lavish elegance, with spacious and exquisitely designed rooms featuring luxurious amenities and stunning views of the bay. Enjoy world-class farm-to-table dining at the hotel's restaurant, where each dish is crafted with locally sourced ingredients. Embrace the surroundings by kayaking or paddleboarding, or simply unwind by the fireplace in the cozy lounge area. .

From

324£ /per night
8.2
Very good (8)

Sunset Beach

4
35 Shore Road
Escape to tranquility at Sunset Beach, an intimate hotel that exudes serenity and calm. This boutique property offers a selection of beautifully designed rooms and cottages, each providing a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Enjoy the laid-back beach vibe, with easy access to the hotel's private beach where you can relax and soak up the sun. Indulge in delectable cuisine at the hotel's restaurant or enjoy a cocktail at the beachfront bar. .

From

475£ /per night

Other city in Country

Fort Lauderdale
Queensbury
San Francisco
Nashville
Manning
Clearwater
Bessemer
Hillsboro
Litchfield
Fullerton
Montgomery
Palm Beach

Other city in World

Scarborough
Wembley
Seville
Leicester
Whitby
Agadir
Doncaster
Benalmadena
Bradford (West Yorkshire)
Torremolinos
Reading
Split