Tourist VR
flag

Shelter Island Hotels

Shelter Island
Jan 19, 2025 - Jan 20, 2025
2 adults, 1 room
Find
Shelter Island Hotels

Discover Your Perfect Stay

Nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, Shelter Island is a hidden gem that offers a serene escape from the bustle of city life. Known for its stunning natural beauty and tranquil ambiance, this quaint island boasts a variety of accommodations that cater to every type of traveler. From charming boutique hotels to luxurious resorts, the Shelter Island hotels provide the perfect base for exploring the island's enchanting beaches, scenic trails, and rich history.

For those seeking a cozy retreat, several Shelter Island hotels offer unique character and personalized service. Picture yourself unwinding in a beautifully appointed room, with easy access to stunning waterfront views and local attractions just a stone's throw away. The inviting atmosphere of these accommodations ensures that you can relax and enjoy the island's peaceful surroundings while still feeling at home.

Luxury seekers will find plenty of high-end options among Shelter Island hotels, featuring upscale amenities and exquisite dining experiences. Whether you're sipping a cocktail by the pool or indulging in a spa treatment, these hotels showcase the best of coastal hospitality. With a variety of outdoor activities, including kayaking and bike rentals, your stay on Shelter Island promises to be both refreshing and memorable, making it the ideal getaway destination.

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
The Pridwin Hotel

9.0 / 10

(79 Reviews)

 From 271£
The Sunset Beach Hotel

8.2 / 10

(8 Reviews)

 From 484£
The Chequit

9.0 / 10

(1 Reviews)

 From 294£
9
Excellent (79)

The Pridwin Hotel

4
81 Shore Road
The Pridwin Hotel combines classic charm with upscale comfort, making it one of the premier luxury Shelter Island hotels. With breathtaking views of Shelter Island Bay, this hotel offers beautifully designed rooms and suites, perfect for a refined getaway. Guests can indulge at the on-site restaurant, which serves meticulously crafted dishes focusing on fresh, local ingredients. The hotel also features a private beach, a heated outdoor pool, and easy access to bike rentals for exploring the island’s natural beauty. With its rich history and top-notch services, the Pridwin Hotel ensures a memorable stay. Experience the best of Shelter Island luxury at this iconic hotel.

From

271£ /per night
8.2
Very good (8)

The Sunset Beach Hotel

4
35 Shore Road
The Sunset Beach Hotel is a breathtaking choice among waterfront Shelter Island hotels, offering stunning views of both the bay and sandy beaches. The hotel features meticulously designed rooms that capture the essence of coastal living with a blend of elegance and comfort. Guests can unwind at the beachside bar and enjoy cocktails while overlooking the water or indulge in fresh seafood dishes at the hotel restaurant. The property also has a private beach area, perfect for relaxing during sunny days. With paddleboard and kayak rentals available, guests can explore the coastline at their leisure. The Sunset Beach Hotel provides a luxurious escape on the water's edge, making for an unforgettable stay.

From

484£ /per night

Romantic Retreats in Shelter Island Hotels

In search of a romantic getaway? The Shelter Island hotels offer a charming selection of accommodations perfect for couples looking to escape and reconnect. With stunning waterfront views, intimate dining experiences, and cozy atmospheres, these hotels provide the ideal backdrop for a memorable retreat. Whether you want to enjoy sunset strolls on the beach or indulge in couples’ spa treatments, the romantic options on Shelter Island cater to every love story. These hotels not only provide comfort but also create an ambiance of intimacy and tranquility. Here are some top recommendations for a romantic stay.

9
Excellent (1)

The Chequit

4
23 Grand Ave
The Chequit is a charming historic hotel that perfectly embodies the spirit of Shelter Island hotels. With its quaint rooms adorned with local artwork and vintage furnishings, couples will feel right at home. This boutique hotel features beautifully landscaped gardens, a delightful outdoor bar, and proximity to scenic walking paths. Enjoy a leisurely breakfast at the on-site café, or dine at nearby restaurants that emphasize locally sourced ingredients. The welcoming staff contributes to an overall intimate experience, ensuring that every moment spent here is special. A stay at The Chequit promises an enchanting retreat for couples.

From

294£ /per night