Best Shelter Island Beach hotels, NY

Name of hotel	Accommodation Rating	Price, $
The Pridwin Hotel	9.4 / 10 (79 Reviews)	From 330US$
The Ram's Head Inn	7.9 / 10 (47 Reviews)	From 407US$
The Harborfront Inn	8.4 / 10 (209 Reviews)	From 159US$
House on Chase Creek	8.2 / 10 (22 Reviews)	From 458US$
Sunset Beach	8.2 / 10 (8 Reviews)	From 596US$

The Pridwin Hotel

81 Shore Road

The Pridwin Hotel is a charming family-oriented option, situated near the picturesque Crescent Beach. This hotel emphasizes a welcoming environment, boasting accommodations that comfortably fit families of various sizes. Guests can enjoy recreational activities such as tennis, sailing, and fishing, promoting quality time spent together outdoors. The hotel’s on-site dining options cater well to kids and adults alike, ensuring everyone finds something they love. Furthermore, its proximity to local attractions makes it easy to explore the beauty of Shelter Island, enhancing any family trip. The Pridwin Hotel offers an inviting experience akin to the Shelter Island Beach Hotel, making it a desirable family retreat.

From

330US$ /per night

The Ram's Head Inn

108 Ram Island Drive

Nestled in a serene corner of Shelter Island is an enchanting venue perfect for a romantic getaway. With its rustic charm and waterfront views, this hotel creates an inviting ambiance that allows couples to relax and reconnect. The on-site restaurant offers exquisite dining options, featuring locally sourced ingredients and fine wines to complement your meal. Strolling through the beautifully manicured gardens or lounging by the private beach makes for unforgettable moments shared together. Every room at the inn exudes warmth and comfort, providing the ideal setting for romance. This hotel stands out as a perfect complement to the atmosphere of the Shelter Island Beach Hotel.

From

407US$ /per night

Family-Friendly Retreats at Shelter Island Beach Hotel

When planning a family vacation, it’s essential to find accommodations that cater to the needs of all ages. The following hotels are chosen for their family-friendly amenities and convenient locations on Shelter Island, making them perfect alternatives to the popular Shelter Island Beach Hotel. These selected hotels provide plenty of activities and comfortable lodging for families, ensuring that everyone has a memorable experience. With spacious rooms and areas for kids to play, these options make family bonding during vacation an ease. Each of these hotels captures the essence of Shelter Island while promising a comfortable stay. Discover the family-friendly charm they offer and how they can complement your visit to the Shelter Island Beach Hotel.

The Harborfront Inn

209 Front Street

Positioned near the waterfront, The Harborfront Inn offers a budget-friendly stay without sacrificing comfort. This cozy inn features well-appointed rooms that provide home-like amenities for travelers. Guests can enjoy complimentary breakfast and access to the inn’s common areas, which include a beautiful terrace perfect for relaxing after a day of exploration. The convenient location allows visitors to discover local shops, restaurants, and attractions, keeping them engaged in the vibrant community. With a focus on guest satisfaction, the Harborfront Inn provides an enjoyable environment without the hefty price tag. This inn offers an excellent budget option comparable to what one might find at the Shelter Island Beach Hotel.

From

159US$ /per night

House on Chase Creek

3 Locust Avenue

House on Chase Creek is a stunning example of sustainable hospitality, featuring eco-friendly practices that blend seamlessly with luxury. This charming property focuses on utilizing local resources and offers organic amenities to enhance guest experience while minimizing environmental impact. With lush gardens that promote wildlife and native plant growth, guests can enjoy nature right outside their windows. The accommodations reflect a cozy and green ethos, creating a peaceful atmosphere for relaxation. By choosing local vendors and ingredients, the House on Chase Creek supports the community while delivering exceptional service. This hotel beautifully aligns with the ethos of the Shelter Island Beach Hotel yet stands out for its eco-conscious initiatives.

From

458US$ /per night

Romantic Getaways at Shelter Island Beach Hotel

When it comes to romantic escapes, Shelter Island offers a wealth of charming hotels perfect for couples. The following selections prioritize intimacy, scenic views, and exceptional service, making them ideal alternatives to the beloved Shelter Island Beach Hotel. From cozy ambiance to beautiful waterfront views, each of these hotels creates a serene atmosphere perfect for rekindling romance. These accommodations ensure couples can enjoy quality time together while soaking in the tranquil surroundings of the island. Whether you seek a peaceful retreat or a bit of adventure, these romantic options cater to every couple's needs. Discover how each venue aligns with the allure of the Shelter Island Beach Hotel for a perfect getaway.

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Road

Sunset Beach is a pet-friendly haven, allowing guests to share their adventure with their beloved pets. The hotel features accommodations designed for those traveling with animals, ensuring comfort for both the guests and their furry friends. Visitors can enjoy beach access where pets are welcome, providing ample opportunity for fun and play in the sand and surf. The hotel's relaxed atmosphere fosters a sense of community among pet owners, making it a delightful place to meet others sharing similar interests. With its combination of beautiful beachfront views and pet-friendly policies, Sunset Beach stands as a great alternative to the Shelter Island Beach Hotel for pet lovers.

From

596US$ /per night