Tourist VR

B&B Shelter Island

Not Just Any Hotel – Only the Best B&B Shelter Island, Selected for You!

Shelter Island
Mar 14, 2025 - Mar 15, 2025
2 adults, 1 room
Find
Tourist VR
United States Hotels
New York State Hotels
B&B Shelter Island
Price per night:
Up to $100
$100 - 200
From $200
Rating:
Excellent 9+
Very good 8+
Good 7+
All ratings
Star rating:
5-stars
4-stars
3-stars
Unrated
8.4
Very good (10)
Rams Head Inn
2
View map · 2.4 mi City Centre
From
407US$ /per night
Sunset Beach
View map · 1.6 mi City Centre
From
0US$ /per night
8.6
Excellent (8)
Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island
4
View map · 1.2 mi City Centre
From
823US$ /per night
8.6
Excellent (43)
The Pridwin Hotel
4
View map · 1.9 mi City Centre
From
334US$ /per night
7.8
Very good (26)
Sunset Beach
4
View map · 1.5 mi City Centre
From
596US$ /per night

Discover Your Perfect Stay

Shelter Island is a hidden gem nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, offering a serene escape for travelers seeking peace and relaxation. Known for its picturesque landscapes, charming waterfronts, and vibrant local culture, it stands out as an ideal destination. Among the many accommodation options, bed and breakfasts in Shelter Island provide a unique experience that blends comfort with the warmth of hospitality.

Staying at a bed and breakfast allows guests to immerse themselves in the gentle rhythm of island life, with each establishment offering its own charm and character. Many of these cozy havens are set in historic homes or within lush gardens, creating a tranquil backdrop for your stay. Your hosts often go above and beyond to ensure a memorable experience, from serving homemade breakfasts featuring local ingredients to providing insider tips on the best nearby attractions.

Exploring the island is a delightful journey, with opportunities for outdoor adventures and cultural experiences just a stone's throw from your bed and breakfast. Take leisurely strolls along the sandy beaches, visit the bustling local shops, or indulge in fresh seafood at one of the nearby restaurants. Whether you're looking for a romantic getaway, a family-friendly retreat, or a solo adventure, the bed and breakfast options in Shelter Island offer the perfect home base for your exploration.

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
The Ram's Head Inn

7.9 / 10

(47 Reviews)

 From 407US$
Sunset Beach Hotel

8.2 / 10

(8 Reviews)

 From 596US$
The House on Chase Creek

8.2 / 10

(22 Reviews)

 From 107US$
7.9
Very good (47)

The Ram's Head Inn

2
108 Ram Island Drive
The Ram's Head Inn stands out for its sustainability initiatives, emphasizing eco-conscious practices while providing a warm and welcoming atmosphere for guests. This lovely bed and breakfast incorporates energy-saving appliances and promotes responsible water usage throughout the property. Guests enjoy breakfast featuring local, organic ingredients, supporting nearby farmers while indulging in the fresh flavors of the region. With beautiful outdoor spaces and nearby nature trails, guests can immerse themselves in the natural beauty of Shelter Island while embracing eco-tourism. The serene setting, combined with a commitment to sustainability, ensures a memorable stay. The Ram's Head Inn is an excellent choice for responsible travelers seeking a bed and breakfast Shelter Island NY.

From

407US$ /per night
8.2
Very good (8)

Sunset Beach Hotel

4
35 Shore Road
Sunset Beach Hotel is a stunning boutique hotel that merges luxury with a laid-back beach vibe, making it a premier choice among bed and breakfast Shelter Island NY. The hotel features chic, stylish rooms that reflect a cozy coastal aesthetic, equipped with lavish bedding and thoughtful amenities for a lavish experience. Guests can enjoy scrumptious breakfast options that celebrate the local culinary scene, often complemented by an ocean view. The hotel is conveniently located near the beach, allowing for leisurely strolls and picturesque sunsets, further enhancing the romantic setting. With its commitment to exceptional service and attention to detail, Sunset Beach Hotel is a perfect balance of luxury and comfort for a memorable stay. Experience the fusion of island charm and upscale comfort at this exceptional bed and breakfast.

From

596US$ /per night

Historic Charm of Bed and Breakfasts in Shelter Island, NY

When visiting Shelter Island the historic charm of bed and breakfasts provides a wonderful opportunity to connect with the island's rich heritage. These accommodations often feature beautifully preserved architecture and enchanting interiors that evoke a sense of nostalgia. Guests can enjoy a unique blend of comfort and character while being pampered with personalized service and home-cooked meals. The atmosphere in these historic bed and breakfasts often reflects the island's past, making them an ideal choice for history enthusiasts. This section highlights some of the top establishments that embody the spirit of this timeless destination. Dive into the delightful offerings at these historic gems as you plan your getaway to the enchanting bed and breakfast Shelter Island NY.

8.2
Very good (22)

The House on Chase Creek

4
3 Locust Avenue
The House on Chase Creek is not only a charming bed and breakfast but also committed to sustainable practices that benefit both guests and the environment. The inn features stylishly decorated rooms designed with energy-efficient amenities, ensuring a comfortable stay with a low carbon footprint. Breakfast includes locally sourced ingredients with an emphasis on organic food, offering wholesome and delicious options each morning. Nestled among scenic beauty, the expansive gardens encourage local wildlife and pollinators, providing a serene retreat for nature lovers. The property’s location allows easy access to nature trails and beaches promoting an adventurous exploration of the island's environment. The House on Chase Creek exemplifies the ethos of a bed and breakfast Shelter Island NY while maintaining a strong commitment to eco-friendly practices.

From

107US$ /per night

Other city in United States

San Diego
Burlington
Milwaukee
Charlotte
Erie
Jim Thorpe
Branson
Charlottesville
Portland
Santa Fe
Glenwood Springs
Sevierville

Other city in World

Rome
Lourdes
Glasgow
Bellingham
Bristol
Belfast
Venice
Durham
Manchester
Jasper
Madrid
Verona